Share graphic for “Use a (More) Private Email Provider” by Joe Levi

Small Acts of Privacy, Part 3

Use a (More) Private Email Provider

Your email address is the key to almost everything in your digital life. Password resets, bank statements, medical portals, and school notices all land there. This small act is about moving that inbox somewhere that can't read it. We'll focus on Proton Mail: what it protects, what it doesn't, and why the difference matters.

What is it?

Proton Mail is an encrypted email service with apps for the web, phones, and computers. It works like any other email account, and you can write to anyone. The difference is that your stored mail is encrypted with keys only you hold, so Proton itself can't read your messages or attachments [1].

Why does this matter?

Most email providers keep your messages in a form they can read. That means the provider, anyone who breaches it, and anyone who serves it with a legal order can read them too. A private provider shrinks that exposure for the content of your mail. It does not make you invisible, and that part matters just as much.

Who does it apply to?

Anyone with an email address, especially people whose inbox holds medical, legal, financial, or family records. That includes small-business owners, journalists, and church and community volunteers.

Where Proton came from

Proton was founded in Switzerland in 2014 by scientists who met at CERN, the physics laboratory where the World Wide Web was born. More than 10,000 people crowdfunded its launch [2].

In June 2024, Proton's founders donated shares to create the nonprofit Proton Foundation, now the primary shareholder of Proton AG, the for-profit company that runs the service. No change of control can happen without the foundation's consent [3]. Proton has no venture capital investors and is paid for by subscriptions.

Why Switzerland?

Proton chose Switzerland on purpose [4].

  1. Outside U.S. and EU jurisdiction. Swiss law makes it a crime for a Swiss company to hand data directly to foreign authorities. Foreign police have to go through Swiss authorities, and the request has to meet Swiss legal standards [4][5].
  2. Strong privacy law. Switzerland protects privacy in its constitution, and Proton says access to data like your subject lines requires an order approved by a Swiss judge [4][1].
  3. Neutrality. Switzerland isn't part of the Five Eyes, Nine Eyes, or Fourteen Eyes intelligence-sharing agreements [4].

That picture is changing. In 2025, the Swiss government proposed revising its surveillance ordinance (VÜPF) so that larger email, messaging, VPN, and cloud providers would have to identify users and retain metadata such as IP addresses [6][7]. In July 2025, Proton announced it was moving most of its physical infrastructure out of Switzerland because of that legal uncertainty, starting with its AI assistant, with servers in Germany and new facilities in Norway [8][6]. Proton has said this doesn't mean leaving Switzerland, and the company is still headquartered in Geneva [2][6]. As of this writing, the revision has not taken effect. After pushback from Swiss lawmakers and industry, the government agreed to rework the draft and hold a second public consultation [7].

What Proton Mail does well

  1. Zero-access encryption. Every message in your inbox, even mail from Gmail users, is stored so Proton can't read the body or attachments [1].
  2. End-to-end encryption between Proton users. Mail between Proton addresses is encrypted on the sender's device and decrypted only on the recipient's [1].
  3. Password-protected email to anyone. You can send an encrypted message to a Gmail or Outlook user, who opens it with a password you share separately [9].
  4. Open source. Proton's apps are open source and independently audited [10].
  5. No ads. Proton doesn't sell your data or show you ads [2].
  6. Aliases. Proton bought SimpleLogin in 2022 [11]. Its "hide-my-email" aliases give each website its own forwarding address, so your real one stays private [12].
  7. A transparency report. Proton publishes its legal orders each year. In 2025, it received 9,301 for Proton Mail and contested 988 [5].

What Proton Mail can't hide

This is the part most people miss. Encryption protects what you say. It doesn't hide who you are talking to.

  1. Metadata is not end-to-end encrypted. Subject lines are not end-to-end encrypted, to stay compatible with email standards [1]. Email also can't be delivered without the sender's and recipient's addresses and a timestamp, so those stay readable too [13]. Under a Swiss order, Proton can also be forced to start logging a specific account's IP address [14]. That information can be handed over, and it has been.
    1. France, 2021. French police, working through Europol and Swiss authorities, obtained a legally binding Swiss order. Proton logged the IP address and device information of an account used by climate activists in Paris and handed it over, and one activist was later arrested [14][15]. Proton couldn't hand over a single message, but the metadata still ended up in a police file.
    2. Spain, 2024. Spanish police, through Swiss police, asked Proton for information about an account tied to a Catalan independence activist. Proton provided the account's recovery email, an iCloud address. Apple then gave police a full name, two home addresses, and a linked Gmail account [16].
    3. Atlanta, reported 2026. In March 2026, 404 Media reported that, according to an FBI affidavit it reviewed, Proton gave Swiss authorities the payment information for an email account tied to the "Stop Cop City" protests in Atlanta. Swiss authorities passed it to the FBI, which used it to identify the person allegedly behind the account [17][18]. Proton says it gave nothing to the FBI directly and only complied with a Swiss order [17]. I first saw this case in a Freedom of the Press Foundation newsletter [13], and I haven't seen the court record myself, so treat the details as reported, not independently verified. Even if the details turn out to be untrue, the scenario is very real: payment details tied to an account can identify its owner.
  2. Regular email is only as private as the other side. When you write to a Gmail user, Google holds a readable copy [1].
  3. Your account details can identify you. A recovery email, a recovery phone number, and payment information can all tie an account to your real name. The Spanish case started with a recovery email [16], the Atlanta case reportedly with payment details [17], and Freedom of the Press Foundation advises that most people should assume they are identifiable on Proton [13].
  4. Your IP address needs separate protection. To hide where you're connecting from, use a trustworthy VPN or Tor.
  5. It's less convenient. Using Outlook, Apple Mail, or Thunderbird requires Proton Mail Bridge, which needs a paid plan [19]. Searching message content works only from an index you build on your own device [20]. The free plan includes 1 GB of storage and one address [21].
  6. Encryption can't protect you from the recipient. Anyone you write to can forward, print, or screenshot your message.

Practical fixes:

  1. Write boring subject lines. "Question" works as well as "My biopsy results."
  2. If you need anonymity, don't add a recovery email or phone tied to your real identity, and store your recovery phrase somewhere safe instead.
  3. Connect through a VPN or Tor when it matters.
  4. Use aliases so websites never see your main address.
  5. Invite the people you write to most to Proton.

A big step up from the inbox you have now

Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo are built on business models that depend on advertising and data. Until 2017, Google scanned the content of free Gmail accounts to personalize the ads it showed you. It announced that year that it would stop [22]. But Google, Microsoft, and Yahoo can still read your stored mail, and they can be compelled to hand it over.

They also cooperate with governments, agencies, and police as a matter of routine. Google runs a dedicated online portal, its Law Enforcement Request System, for agencies to submit requests [23]. In the second half of 2025 alone, Google reported more than 50,000 U.S. subpoenas, search warrants, and court orders for user data [24], and Microsoft publishes similar reports [25]. Some of that cooperation needs no warrant or subpoena at all. U.S. law lets a provider hand over your messages and records voluntarily if it believes in good faith that an emergency involving danger of death or serious physical injury requires it [26]. Google calls these emergency disclosure requests, and it received 4,261 of them from U.S. authorities in that same six months [24][27]. Proton can't produce what it can't read.

Proton Mail isn't an invisibility cloak. But moving your inbox there takes the contents of your mail off the table for advertisers, data thieves, and fishing expeditions. That's a huge improvement for the cost of a new address and an afternoon of updating accounts.

Nothing to Hide

"If you've done nothing wrong, why do you need private email?" Because your inbox is a record of your life, not a confession. It holds your tax returns, lab results, and kids' report cards. Wanting that kept away from advertisers, hackers, and strangers is common sense. Privacy protects ordinary people from having ordinary details turned against them, and laws, governments, and the definition of "wrong" can all change after the fact.

Get Your Family on Board

  1. Start with yourself. Open a Proton account and use it for a week before recommending it.
  2. Move one important thing first. Use it for your bank and medical portals, or create a family address for school and household mail.
  3. Forward, don't abandon. Keep the old account for a while and forward it to Proton, so no one misses a message.
  4. Set it up for them. Install the app, turn on two-factor authentication, and save the recovery phrase together.
  5. Explain the tradeoffs honestly. Tell them it protects what they write, not who they write to, and that boring subject lines help.

Sources

  1. Proton Support, "How Proton Mail messages are encrypted." https://proton.me/support/proton-mail-encryption-explained (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 1, use 1 of 6↩2 Back to citation 1, use 2 of 6↩3 Back to citation 1, use 3 of 6↩4 Back to citation 1, use 4 of 6↩5 Back to citation 1, use 5 of 6↩6 Back to citation 1, use 6 of 6
  2. Proton, "About Proton." https://proton.me/about (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 2, use 1 of 3↩2 Back to citation 2, use 2 of 3↩3 Back to citation 2, use 3 of 3
  3. Yen, Andy. "Proton is transitioning towards a non-profit structure." Proton, June 17, 2024. https://proton.me/blog/proton-non-profit-foundation (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 3
  4. Proton, "Why Switzerland? An analysis of Swiss privacy laws." https://proton.me/blog/switzerland (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 4, use 1 of 4↩2 Back to citation 4, use 2 of 4↩3 Back to citation 4, use 3 of 4↩4 Back to citation 4, use 4 of 4
  5. Proton, "Transparency report" (last modified January 6, 2026). https://proton.me/legal/transparency (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 5, use 1 of 2↩2 Back to citation 5, use 2 of 2
  6. heise online, "Surveillance: Proton relocates parts of its infrastructure from Switzerland," August 16, 2025. https://www.heise.de/en/news/Surveillance-Proton-relocates-parts-of-its-infrastructure-from-Switzerland-10538664.html (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 6, use 1 of 3↩2 Back to citation 6, use 2 of 3↩3 Back to citation 6, use 3 of 3
  7. SWI swissinfo.ch, "Switzerland juggles fighting crime against threat to tech-privacy industry," September 11, 2026. https://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/foreign-affairs/switzerland-juggles-fighting-crime-against-threat-to-tech-privacy-industry/91999749 (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 7, use 1 of 2↩2 Back to citation 7, use 2 of 2
  8. Maguire, Eamonn. "Introducing Lumo, the AI where every conversation is confidential." Proton, July 23, 2025. https://proton.me/blog/lumo-ai (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 8
  9. Proton Support, "Password-protected emails." https://proton.me/support/password-protected-emails (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 9
  10. Proton, "An open source privacy company." https://proton.me/community/open-source (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 10
  11. Proton, "Proton and SimpleLogin are joining forces," April 8, 2022. https://proton.me/blog/proton-and-simplelogin-join-forces (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 11
  12. Proton Support, "Hide-my-email aliases." https://proton.me/support/pass-email-alias (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 12
  13. Freedom of the Press Foundation, "Proton Mail is not for anonymity," March 11, 2026. https://freedom.press/digisec/blog/proton-mail-is-not-for-anonymity/ (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 13, use 1 of 3↩2 Back to citation 13, use 2 of 3↩3 Back to citation 13, use 3 of 3
  14. Proton, "Important clarifications regarding arrest of climate activist," September 6, 2021. https://proton.me/blog/climate-activist-arrest (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 14, use 1 of 2↩2 Back to citation 14, use 2 of 2
  15. TechCrunch, "ProtonMail logged IP address of French activist after order by Swiss authorities," September 6, 2021. https://techcrunch.com/2021/09/06/protonmail-logged-ip-address-of-french-activist-after-order-by-swiss-authorities/ (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 15
  16. TechCrunch, "Encrypted services Apple, Proton and Wire helped Spanish police identify activist," May 8, 2024. https://techcrunch.com/2024/05/08/encrypted-services-apple-proton-and-wire-helped-spanish-police-identify-activist/ (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 16, use 1 of 2↩2 Back to citation 16, use 2 of 2
  17. Cox, Joseph. "Proton Mail Helped FBI Unmask Anonymous 'Stop Cop City' Protester." 404 Media, March 5, 2026. https://www.404media.co/proton-mail-helped-fbi-unmask-anonymous-stop-cop-city-protestor/ (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 17, use 1 of 3↩2 Back to citation 17, use 2 of 3↩3 Back to citation 17, use 3 of 3
  18. The Verge, "Proton's security and privacy policies can't always keep your payment information hidden" (2026). https://www.theverge.com/policy/890278/proton-mail-stop-cop-city-fbi (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 18
  19. Proton, "Proton Mail Bridge." https://proton.me/mail/bridge (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 19
  20. Proton Support, "How to search your Proton Mail messages." https://proton.me/support/search-message-content (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 20
  21. Proton, "Proton Mail pricing." https://proton.me/mail/pricing (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 21
  22. Greene, Diane. "As G Suite gains traction in the enterprise, G Suite's Gmail and consumer Gmail to more closely align." Google, June 23, 2017. https://blog.google/products/gmail/g-suite-gains-traction-in-the-enterprise-g-suites-gmail-and-consumer-gmail-to-more-closely-align/ (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 22
  23. Google, "Law Enforcement Request System." https://lers.google.com/ (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 23
  24. Google Transparency Report, "Requests for user information" (United States). https://transparencyreport.google.com/user-data/overview (opens in a new tab)↩1 Back to citation 24, use 1 of 2↩2 Back to citation 24, use 2 of 2
  25. Microsoft, "Law Enforcement Requests Report." https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/corporate-responsibility/law-enforcement-requests-report (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 25
  26. 18 U.S.C. § 2702, "Voluntary disclosure of customer communications or records," Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School. https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2702 (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 26
  27. Google, "How Google handles government requests for user information." https://policies.google.com/terms/information-requests (opens in a new tab)↩ Back to citation 27

← All articles · Small Acts of Privacy